I remember the dark room, closed door. My eyes ached. I ached. Seventy years later, I can still see the darkness.
Rubeola.
I could have died from it. Hundreds of kids like me did die every year, and that was a normal, usual, childhood disease. Some got encephalitis and survived, brain damaged, others died from…
Measles.
UCD. Usual Childhood Diseases. On medical records, you might still see this term.
When 100 children now die from influenza in a season, the country more than twice as populated as back then, it’s newsworthy. Back then, estimates were 500,000 measles cases annually in children. Virtually everybody got it, for measles is one of the most infectious diseases. The death rate was ten-fold higher per capita than influenza. What we didn’t know then was measles damaged the immune system for an extended period. I wonder how that manifested with me. I had many strep throats. Could that have been a factor?
The following is my experience with UCD as a child and as a physician. The 6% of Americans my age or older have had similar experiences. We knew these diseases first hand. We all knew those who either died or had complications. These plagues are not extinct. They will return if we ever let down our guard. These diseases are not dichotomies between live or die; there are many in-between permanent complications, such as…
Rubella, a get out of school free card because we usually felt well, despite the rash. My wife was asymptomatic when a classmate diagnosed her. Adults knew, however, that rubella was far worse if a woman were infected while in the first trimester of pregnancy. My wife’s cousin was infected while pregnant during the rubella epidemic in the 1960s; her son was born with congenital rubella syndrome. He was deaf, leading to an obvious speech impediment, and had cataracts. Life is difficult enough when one is healthy; starting life deaf, limited vision, and trouble speaking puts one at a huge permanent disadvantage. His mother became a caregiver because of a disease which can now be prevented. Several lives were affected for every case. Twenty thousand had the syndrome in the early 1960s, but after licensure of the vaccine in 1969, there were about 100 cases per year in the 1970s, single digits annually now. These diseases occurred. UCD. Everybody got rubella, but many of us didn’t see the kids with congenital rubella.
We don’t know the potential lost with congenital rubella and other complications of UCD. It cost the son and his mother an incalculable amount, but we don’t measure or graph “incalculable” in economics. It is ignored. Lost productivity has a dollar sign, but happiness, joy, lack of pain, no disability, or having a child grow into an independent adult are more valuable even if unmeasurable. Had the rubella vaccine existed a decade earlier, the above tragedy never would have occurred. If we stop rubella vaccination, this story can recur, perhaps without a pregnant woman’s even knowing she had the disease.
We all got varicella, chickenpox, too. My wife remembers wearing mittens on her hands to prevent scarring of her face when she scratched. The disease for an individual wasn’t by mid-century standards bad, despite the death rate’s being triple compared to childhood influenza in a bad year today. Chickenpox never made the news. Everybody got it. Chickenpox is now dangerous for the many who are immunosuppressed. It also sets the stage for later infections with herpes virus, leading to zoster or shingles, and post-herpetic neuralgia is a nasty, miserable, difficult to treat condition. Two doses of the vaccine have a very high probability of lifelong protection.
A brother of mine had polio, fortunately not paralytic, but our parents feared summers and going to swimming pools or the beach because of potential spread of the disease. We grew up seeing March of Dimes money collection folders on store counters with pictures of children in iron lungs. I saw real people in them when I was a third year medical student. Unvaccinated young people traveling in the third world today are at risk for paralytic polio, a completely preventable disaster. Polio doesn’t care what color your passport is.
My other brother had mumps meningitis, fortunately not severe, but mumps can cause deafness and orchitis; the latter potentially causing sterility. When I was a Navy doctor, a sailor with a small testicle post- mumps had his vas deferens, which connects the ejaculatory duct to the urethra, twist and cut off circulation to his testis, a torsion. This causes excruciating pain, like any blocked tube in the body, and especially for the testis. As a doctor right out of internship, I had never seen a testicular torsion, and I never would again, but the diagnosis was obvious. I successfully untwisted the torsion. The sailor was later found to be sterile. We now have a good vaccine for mumps.
When my wife and I were medical students, we went to the Crow Reservation in Montana, where earlier that spring there were three cases of culture proven diphtheria. In 1972. My father-in-law, who practiced ENT, told me that while throat membranes caused by the corynebacterium could lead to death from aspiration, what killed children was diphtheria toxin, a protein causing widespread organ damage including myocarditis, inflammation of the heart. Usual childhood disease. He saw a lot of it.
The first spinal tap I ever did was on a 2 year-old girl with stiff neck and fever. She had H.influenzae (H. flu; Hib) meningitis, which then afflicted 20,000 annually with 1000 deaths. She was treated immediately with antibiotics and eventually went home, but her parents may have wondered for years whether she could have suffered minor brain damage. We had a vaccine for Hib 7 years later that decreased the number of cases 99.5% with no deaths in 2021. Who would deny any vaccination that is so effective and risk Hib?
My mother had both whooping cough and scarlatina, the latter a strep infection with a specific toxin. My father had tuberculosis. We children wore white band-aid patches on our backs for a few days in summer to test for the disease. I have a small scar near my left shoulder where I was vaccinated for smallpox. Finally, I add two more Rs, roseola with its high fever and rash, and RSV, not known as a disorder until 1956. Having a vaccine for RSV is thrilling.
Usual Childhood Diseases became Unusual Childhood Diseases in my lifetime in one of the great triumphs of medicine. One may almost say that nobody gets these any more, a tribute to vaccine efficacy. The Salk Vaccine was so effective that the study was stopped early to start treating people sooner. I was in the first cohort for the Sabin oral vaccine. We must continue them and others.
I know many feel they must experience something in order to believe it. Having had measles, the sickest I’ve ever been in my life, I can confidently say one does not want to experience it. Ever.
Three messages from my generation: first, ignore these diseases at your or your children’s or grandchildren’s peril. Literally. Second, given the cost of treating these illnesses and their complications, vaccines are one of the most cost-effective treatments in existence. Finally, because these diseases didn’t happen doesn’t mean they were never possible, and not having a dollar sign value for something that didn’t occur does not make it any less valuable.








